Skip to main content

Caramelized Butternut Squash

Cookbook
Author(s): Ina Garten, Martha Stewart
Page 151
barefoot contessa butternut CSA fall ina garten squash vegetable

Photos (1)

Reviews

5 reviews, average rating 4.4 / 5

Queezle_Sister

14 years ago
4/5
3 found this helpful Sign in to mark helpful
Rich and sweet. Butternut squash is cut into cubes, and mixed with butter, brown sugar, salt and pepper. A long roasting time (about an hour) leads to nicely carmelized squares of bright orange squash.
For flavor and appearance, this recipe deserves a 5.
Why "only" four? Butternut squash starts out sweet, and it doesn't really need all that butter and brown sugar to be excellent. I felt that the recipe took a really healthy ingredient, and made it less healthy.
On the other hand, i...
Read more
Report

kateq

14 years ago
4/5
2 found this helpful Sign in to mark helpful
Quite delicious and very easy, this roasted squash doesn't seem to me to use such an extravagant amount of sugar and butter and salt--once I had peeled and seeded my squash I had two pounds of flesh. I used 2 tablespoons of sugar, 3 tablespoons of butter and less than a teaspoon of salt. Ironically, quite a bit of the sugar and butter remained in the pan, caramelized around the edges of the silpat (thank goodness I used it---this would have been a messy pan to clean otherwise) and so the squas... Read more
Report

Peckish Sister

14 years ago
4/5
1 found this helpful Sign in to mark helpful

I also used one large squash which equaled half the recipe. I followed the directions to the letter using a glass 9 X 13” pan. The directions worked perfectly. I couldn’t "see” the brown sugar, but it sure worked to bring out the sweet flavor of the squash. I would not change a thing about this recipe.

Report

bhnyc

14 years ago
5/5
1 found this helpful Sign in to mark helpful

I love this! It's great served with the Baked Ham- or really with anything on a nice fall evening.

Report

lovesgenoise

14 years ago
5/5
2 found this helpful Sign in to mark helpful

IMHO, this is worth the bad food points. It has a fair amount of butter, sugar, and salt, but it makes the squash perfect. I tried to make it with less sugar and less salt, but when I tasted it near the end of cooking, I quickly decided to add the missing quantities. I was so glad I did, it elevated the dish to something tasty enough for a special occasion.

Report