Skip to main content

Beef and Barley Soup

Cookbook
Author(s): The Editors at America's Test Kitchen, America's Test Kitchen
Page 15
Cuisine: North American
Course: Soups and Stews
America's Test Kitchen beef soup
Recipe photo
Photo by foodiewife

Photos (1)

Reviews

2 reviews, average rating 3.5 / 5

Peckish Sister

14 years ago
4/5
3 found this helpful Sign in to mark helpful

This turned out a well seasoned soup with many requests for the recipe. Since I followed the recipe (except for using a cheaper cut of beef and cutting it up instead of leaving it whole and shredding it later) it did turn out more like a soup than a stew. Personally I would have liked more barley, but that was not the general consensus. Interestingly everyone that was on a low carb diet particularly liked it. I will cook this again, both for home or pot-luck.

1 comment(s)

Queezle_Sister · 14 years ago
So thrilled to see that my Peckish Sister has returned!
Report

foodiewife

12 years ago
3/5
1 found this helpful Sign in to mark helpful

We liked this soup, but I felt that the tomato puree kind of overpowered the beef broth flavor that I like in this type of soup. Also, I would double the amount of barley. Other than that, it's a good recipe that I would make again.

Report