Skip to main content

Parmesan Smashed Potatoes

Cookbook
Author(s): Ina Garten, Martha Stewart
Page 158
easy kid friendly mashed potatoes
Recipe photo
Photo by Queezle_Sister

Photos (1)

Reviews

5 reviews, average rating 4.2 / 5

Peckish Sister

14 years ago
3/5
1 found this helpful Sign in to mark helpful

I used half the butter and substituted buttermilk for the heavy cream, but kept the sour cream. I wished I had added the melted butter first, then added the warmed buttermilk (as in the America Test Kitchen recipe). That way I could have controlled the amount of liquid better. 1 ½ cups turned out way too watery. Don’t use fat-free butter milk, it separates when heating. I liked the suggestion for evaporated milk. This was not a success for me.

Report

bab56

14 years ago
4/5
1 found this helpful Sign in to mark helpful

These are not for the diet concious but very good. I did use yogurt for the sour cream and evaporated milk instead of half and half. These will be on my special occasion menu.

Report

bhnyc

14 years ago
4/5
1 found this helpful Sign in to mark helpful

This is very good and I like that there are chunks of potatoes in it. I do admit to lowering the fat too. It tastes just as good. It goes really well with the Turkey Meatloaf.

Report

Queezle_Sister

14 years ago
5/5
5 found this helpful Sign in to mark helpful

Great flavorful potatoes!

But I must confess to several alterations - largely to cut the fat. But even so, kids and husband couldn't get enough of it!

Now to the changes -- I used 2/3 the butter called for, I replaced the half-and-half with 1% milk, and I replaced the sour cream with yogurt.

3 comment(s)

Peckish Sister · 14 years ago
Thanks for the great tips. I wonder when someone changes a recipe and then doesn't like it, but I am glad that these alterations worked!
Queezle_Sister · 14 years ago
Yes, I'd be reluctant to give a low rating to a recipe I had changed significantly. On the other hand, it does help all of us to know what changes work, and what changes do not work. The kids finished the leftovers (3 lbs of potatoes!) as dessert!
aj12754 · 14 years ago
Very helpful review ... I love the Contessa's flavor profiles but she doesn't stint on the butter and cream. Nice to know that the healthier version you created worked so well.
Report

sturlington

14 years ago
5/5
3 found this helpful Sign in to mark helpful
What's not to like about these potatoes? They are very rich and flavorful. It was also nice that I usually have all the ingredients I need on hand. I halved the recipe and still had plenty of leftovers, because they were so rich that I kept portion sizes small.
I don't have a standing mixer so I just used my potato masher and they came out fine. I finished them using a trick I learned from a local diner. I spooned out the portions on a hot griddle and let them get browned on both sides. They go...
Read more

1 comment(s)

Queezle_Sister · 14 years ago
I love the griddle idea,and combining with eggs. I could see that being a big hit with my carbo-loving kids.
Report